Skip to main content

Allergy-Friendly Witch Cake

by Laura Giletti

Use a safe cake recipe such as:
Wacky Cake 
(can be made free of milk, egg, soy, wheat, gluten, nuts, corn)

Use a safe chocolate frosting such as:
Chocolate Silk Frosting (can be made free of milk, egg, soy, wheat, gluten, nuts, corn)

It is recommended that the cakes be baked a day or two in advance before assembly and decoration.

1. Bake safe cake in multiple layers. For the top layer, use an oven-proof bowl or a small cake pan. Make sure to line the pans with parchment and/or use plenty of shortening in the pans to allow for a clean release when you turn them out. I used a 6" pan for the top and two 8" pans for the lower layers. Each of the two lower layers is a double batch of Wacky Cake and the top layer is a single batch.

2. For cakes made with wheat flour, allow cakes to cool for 10-15 minutes before removing from pans. Gluten-free cakes should be allowed to cool closer to 30 minutes. Once removed from the cake pans, allow cakes to cool completely. They can cool on a countertop overnight, or they can be frozen.


3. Once completely cooled, torte the cakes so that they can sit flat on top of each other. Take your knife and cut the cakes horizontally to level them off. You can also split the layers horizontally so that one layer becomes two and you can get in another layer of frosting, if you are so inclined.

4. Take a round cookie or biscuit cutter and check that your doll will fit through the opening, then use the cutter to make a hole in the middle of each layer. Dry stack the cakes to ensure that the holes line up and that the doll fits. Also check that the skirt is the right height on the doll; if not, make necessary adjustments. Remove doll.


5. Using a long, serrated knife, cut the cake into a dome shape by removing corners. Your frosting will help you smooth it all out later. Remove the layers to prepare for the crumb coat.

6. Prepare a double batch of 
frosting for a crumb coat. Take pieces of parchment and tuck them just under the edge of the bottom layer of cake to keep your cake plate clean. Frost the bottom layer. Add your subsequent layers (add frosting in between layers) and frost the top and sides as you go. Wrap the doll in plastic wrap to keep her clean. Insert the doll into the cake. Allow crumb coat to dry (overnight is preferred).

7. Make another batch of frosting and cover the outside of the cake, being sure to bring the frosting right up around the doll. You can dip your knife in warm water to smooth out the "skirt" or you can put a thick layer of frosting and swirl it with your knife as pictured.

8. Decorate your cake however you like—using a piping bag or candies. Remove the parchment from underneath the bottom layer. Decorate the doll herself with a hat or other accessories.
If you need any assistance adapting these recipes to fit your child's needs, feel free to post on our Food & Cooking forums (requires registration, but it is free to register).
Laura has been a member of KFA since 2005 and has volunteered to help us with our community and statistics for the past several years.  She is the mother of 2 young girls and is an avid cook.  

Copyright © 2012. All rights reserved.


Images (8)
  • Witch Cake: Made with wacky cake (free of dairy, egg, soy, and can be gluten-free too)
  • witch-cake: witch-cake
  • witch-cake1: setup for recipe
  • witch-cake2: torting a cake
  • witch-cake3: make holes in center for doll
  • witch-cake4: Test size of skirt
  • witch-cake5: crumb coat
  • witch-cake7: Finished witch cake

Add Comment

Comments (0)

Kids With Food Allergies
A Division of the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America
1235 South Clark Street Suite 305, Arlington, VA 22202
Phone: 1-800-7-ASTHMA (1.800.727.8462)
Link copied to your clipboard.